The Fray Awards in 2010

Nominated     Grammy Award                          Best Pop Vocal Album

                                                                            for The Fray

Nominated     Grammy Award                          Best Pop Performance

                                                                            by a Duo or Group

                                                                            with Vocal

                                                                            for "Never Say Never"

The Fray Awards in 2009

Nominated     Teen Choice Award                  Choice Music: Rock Track

                                                                            for "You Found Me"

The Fray Awards in 2007  

Nominated     Grammy Award                         Best Pop

                                                                           Vocal Peformance  

                                                                           by a Duo or Group

                                                                           for "Over My Head (Cable Car)"

Nominated     Grammy Award                         Best Rock

                                                                           Vocal Performance

                                                                           by a Duo or Group

                                                                           for "Over My Head (Cable Car)"

The Fray Awards in 2006   

Won               Billboard Music Award            Digital Album 

Won               Billboard Music Award            Digital Songs Artist of the Year 

Nominated     Grammy Award                        Best Pop Performance

                                                                          by a Duo or Group with Vocal 

                                                                          for "Over My Head (Cable Car)"

Nominated     Grammy Award                        Best Rock Performance

                                                                          by a Duo or Group with Vocal 

                                                                          for "How to Save a Life"